Body-Subjects and Disordered Minds: Treating the 'Whole' by Eric Matthews

By Eric Matthews

How should still we take care of psychological sickness - as an "illness" like diabetes or bronchitis, as a "problem in living", or what? This ebook seeks to respond to such questions by way of going to their roots, in philosophical questions on the character of the human brain, the ways that it may be understood, and concerning the nature and goals of clinical medicine.

The controversy over the character of psychological disease and the appropriateness of the "medical model" is not only an summary theoretical debate: it has a pertaining to very sensible problems with applicable therapy, in addition to on psychiatric ethics and legislation. a massive competition of this publication is that those questions are eventually philosophical in personality: they are often resolved provided that we abandon a few common philosophical assumptions in regards to the "mind" and the "body", and approximately what it capability for drugs to be "scientific".

The "phenomenological" strategy of the twentieth-century French thinker, Maurice Merleau-Ponty is used to question those assumptions. His belief of people as "body-subjects" is argued to supply a extra illuminating state of mind approximately psychological affliction and the ways that it may be understood and taken care of. The stipulations we conventionally name "mental disorders" are, it truly is argued, no longer a homogeneous team: the traditional interpretation of the scientific version matches a few extra without problems than others. The middle psychological problems, even though, are most sensible considered as disturbed methods of being on the planet, which reason sadness due to deviation from "human" instead of straightforwardly "biological" norms. that's, they're difficulties in how we adventure the realm and particularly folks, instead of in physiological functioning - even if the character of our event can't finally be separated from the ways that bodies functionality. This research is utilized in the publication either to matters in medical therapy and to the distinctive moral and criminal questions of psychiatry.

Written through a widely known thinker in an available and transparent type, this publication can be of curiosity to quite a lot of readers, from psychiatrists to social employees, legal professionals, ethicists, philosophers and a person with an curiosity in psychological future health.

Show description

Read or Download Body-Subjects and Disordered Minds: Treating the 'Whole' Person in Psychiatry (International Perspectives in Philosophy & Psychiatry) PDF

Similar psychiatry books

Treatment-Resistant Mood Disorders

Even if antidepressants have helped thousands all over the world, a considerable share of sufferers fail to reply or remit. there's little released info to be had to clinicians for analysis and administration of treatment-resistant melancholy, inflicting them to make tricky judgements concerning remedies with very constrained facts.

Evidence-Based Psychotherapies for Children and Adolescents, Second Edition

Broadly considered as a most efficient textual content and medical source, this ebook offers exemplary therapy techniques for a huge variety of social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties in young children and youth. Concise chapters from top professionals describe the conceptual underpinnings of every remedy, how interventions are introduced on a session-by-session foundation, and what the examine exhibits approximately therapy effectiveness.

The Synthesis of Self: Volume 1 the I of Consciousness Development from Birth to Maturity

A psychoanalyst, via education and adventure, directs the en­ tire concentration of his awareness to registering and internalizing the in­ positioned of a patient's communications, listening closely for his or her implied meanings. it is just via umaveling the mysteries of an un­ awake realm of psychological job that it turns into attainable to totally understand the way psychological productions are eventually ob­ servable.

Oxford Textbook of Correctional Psychiatry

Correctional psychiatry has bought expanding reputation as a space of perform with designated abilities and information. The Oxford Textbook of Correctional Psychiatry brings jointly American and foreign specialists to supply a entire review of the sector. scholars and psychiatric citizens will locate uncomplicated details that prepares them for scientific rotations, and psychiatrists operating in jails and prisons will discover a distinctive overview of the complicated matters that come up in those settings.

Additional resources for Body-Subjects and Disordered Minds: Treating the 'Whole' Person in Psychiatry (International Perspectives in Philosophy & Psychiatry)

Sample text

That most people would find interference with their natural functioning undesirable is neither here nor there from the point of view of the meaning of the term disease. All that matters in theoretical medicine is this purely descriptive meaning. What about illness? Illnesses, according to Boorse, are a subclass of diseases. A disease is called [an] illness … only if it is serious enough to be incapacitating, and therefore is (i) undesirable for its bearer; (ii) a title to special treatment; and (iii) a valid excuse for normally criticizable behavior.

The medical model of mental illness thus comes to be the conception of mental disorder as a mechanical fault in the workings of particular systems of the body. It is in this way that the problems referred to in this chapter come to suggest a need to rethink the very basis of scientific medicine, and with it our understanding of ourselves more generally. All these questions will thus need to be raised again, and discussed in more detail, as we proceed. 21 This page intentionally left blank Chapter 2 Illness and disease Being well and being ill When we are in the mood to evaluate our lives, or parts of our lives, we can do so in various ways.

At first sight, Kendell’s account seems as little supported by real argument as Szasz’s. He seems to arrive at his definition of illness by simply taking it for granted that it must be based on the common features of typical bodily disorders. Perhaps, however, there is more to his argument than meets the eye. By picking on biological disadvantage as the key common feature of illnesses, he in a sense both justifies the choice of bodily examples as paradigm cases and allows for the legitimate extension of the term beyond these cases.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.93 of 5 – based on 39 votes