Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science by Brendan Wallace

By Brendan Wallace

A ground-breaking new e-book, past Human errors: Taxonomies and security technology deconstructs the traditional thought of “human mistakes” and offers an entire new method of taking a look at injuries and the way they could be avoided. in keeping with learn conducted within the rail, nuclear, and safety industries, the authors express how, via concentrating exclusively on ”human error,” structures and sociological components are usually overlooked in modern defense technology. in addition they argue that the “information processing” view of human cognition, the root of the vast majority of safeguard technological know-how and ergonomics, is hopelessly simplistic and ends up in useless or perhaps faulty intervention concepts. Wallace and Ross discover how what they name the “technically rational” view of technological know-how can abate the method of constructing a taxonomy of mistakes occasions, and the consequences this has for the present orthodoxy. In laying out the restrictions of the “technically rational” standpoint, they essentially outline their very own replacement procedure. they start through demonstrating that the construction of trustworthy taxonomies is essential and supply examples of the way they created such taxonomies within the nuclear and rail industries. They move directly to supply a critique of traditional “frequentist” facts and supply coherent, effortless to exploit possible choices. They finish via re-analyzing notorious failures resembling theSpace travel Challenger twist of fate to illustrate how the “standard” view of those occasions ignores social and disbursed elements. The publication concludes with a stimulating and provocative description of the results of this new procedure for protection technology, and the social sciences as an entire. whereas delivering a transparent and intelligible creation to the speculation of human errors and modern considering in defense technological know-how, Wallace and Ross mount a problem to the outdated orthodoxy and supply a realistic substitute paradigm.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science PDF

Similar health & safety books

Excavation Systems Planning, Design, and Safety

Get Deep into the sphere of Excavation-Planning, perform, and defense Excavation structures making plans, layout, and defense is a radical advisor to making sure your tasks are accomplished thoroughly, appropriately, and affordably. Concisely written and offered in an easy-to-navigate structure, this accomplished consultant palms you with the most up-tp-date info to be had.

What Went Wrong?, : Case Studies of Process Plant Disasters

Professional Trevor Kletz examines the factors and aftermaths of diverse plant disasters--almost each of that could were avoided. Case histories illustrate what went unsuitable, why it went improper, after which consultant you in tips to stay away from related tragedies. research from the errors of others. This valuable and revered booklet examines the motives and aftermaths of various plant failures - nearly each of which can were avoided.

Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science

A ground-breaking new booklet, past Human mistakes: Taxonomies and safeguard technology deconstructs the traditional thought of “human errors” and gives a complete new means of injuries and the way they may be avoided. in accordance with examine conducted within the rail, nuclear, and security industries, the authors exhibit how, by way of concentrating completely on ”human error,” structures and sociological components are often overlooked in modern protection technological know-how.

Advances in human factors, ergonomics, and safety in manufacturing and service industries

This quantity is worried with the human components, ergonomics, and questions of safety relating to the layout of goods, procedures, and structures, in addition to operation and administration of industrial firms in either production and repair sectors of latest undefined. The ebook is equipped into ten sections that concentrate on the subsequent topics: I: company administration II: Human elements in production III: techniques and providers IV: layout of labor platforms V.

Extra info for Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science

Sample text

It is perhaps ironic that the modern, scientific study of accidents begins with Heinrich as he was not a scientist but worked in the insurance industry in the United States in the 1920s. Nevertheless, in his pioneering work, Industrial Accident Prevention (originally published in 1931), he set out his own view of the methodology and philosophy of the fledgling science [50]. What may be surprising is that, in many ways, safety science has always followed (and continues to follow) in Heinrich’s footsteps.

What methodologies should be used? Should we, for example, like H. W. Heinrich [see 50] (the godfather of the field), attempt to empower management as much as possible and assume that if managers have complete control over workers, then we should see a reduction in the accident rate? Or, should we empower the workers? Should we punish human error (as Heinrich argued)? Or, should we (as Gerald Wilde [28] argued from within the school of risk homeostasis) reward the lack of error? These questions demonstrate Putnam’s [see 17] point: in the real world, facts and values are intertwined, rarely more so than in discussions of safety.

The academics or the practitioners? 1 PHILOSOPHY AND CAUSALITY It was one of the key contentions of David Hume that we do not actually observe causality. We may observe an object coming into contact with another object or a person engaged in an activity prior to an unwanted event, but we can never actually perceive a causal effect directly. Instead, a union in the imagination is formed between certain events, and this (psychological) union is what we refer to as cause [32]. This is one of the (very) few arguments in Western philosophy that has not yet been refuted.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.86 of 5 – based on 29 votes